There is no doubt that the Web 2.0 ecosystem has dramatically shrunk the development time to launch a web-based business. My friend Robin Chase has written several blog posts (Web 2.0 is like Yeast: Rampant Growth Possible) recently about just how easy it is to create these businesses.
So, my question is, how do investors and entrepreneurs think about Web 2.0 business models? What kind of investor is right for your business?
I see three buckets of businesses:
1) The American Idol businesses. Investing in the next face book app, iphone app or web 2.0 idea that takes less than 6 months to develop and has no differentiation other then it is a cool idea. The entrepreneur is hoping for rapid viral adoption like www.fiverr.com.
Investing in these businesses is no different than being a talent agent or a record producer. You are betting that the entrepreneur has talent and a hope that you have the next great singer under contract. You can make a lot of money this way, but it is really hard. There are lots of one hit or no hit wonders out there so you need to keep your investments low in each performer and spread it around among many potential stars. Not the traditional model for most East Coast investors.
There is also a trap for many naïve entrepreneurs. Once you get your site launched or app running, the cost of acquiring customers -unless you are truly viral- often exceeds the potential revenue per customer.
2) The Pizza Parlor businesses – This is the class of businesses that I find most interesting, and I believe has the highest probability for success. These businesses have moderate development times (one half to one man years), but they have a well-defined business model that use Web2.0 tools to change the paradigm for an existing industry.
I am currently working with a Pizza Parlor like company called Careful Products (www.carefulproducts.com) that is using high definition web based video conferencing tools to change the face of the home health care agency business.
Why is this a Pizza Parlor business? When you start a pizza parlor, you need a little bit of capital, a good recipe and some secret sauce. The business takes a little while to make money, but you can operate a single store and make money. Then again, you can open 150 or so stores like Bertucci’s, or you can have 8000 stores like Dominos.
The Pizza Parlor Web2.0 businesses require some industry knowledge, some secret sauce, but they are businesses that can be replicated by others with relatively little investment. These businesses require minimal up front capital, can be profitable at different scales, and investments can be metered out over time. The Pizza Parlor businesses tend to be highly capital efficient and are well aligned to the investment style of many early stage investors these days.
3) The Google Businesses- We all know these business plans. Game changing businesses that are inventing something that is truly new or truly better (as in Google’s case). They require lots of development time and big up front capital. Web2.0 makes these businesses easier, and less capital intensive, but they are still high risk, high reward businesses best suited for large established VCs.
It is not my intention to advocate that one style of business is superior to another, but much more to help entrepreneurs think about the businesses they are building.
Once you figure out if you are the next Eric Lambert, Upper Crust Pizza or Google you will have a much easier time aligning yourself to the right set of investors.
Wednesday, March 24, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

Brad, what to do you consider to be the normal investment in a Pizza Parlor Web 2.0 startup?
ReplyDeleteWhat are your thoughts on doing American Idol-style investments in Pizza Parlor Web 2.0 startups?
American Idol-style investing reminds me of Dave McClure's comments recently at the MIT Enterprise Forum.
Marsh Sutherland
http://socialgrow.com
@socialgrow | @marshsutherland
Marsh,
ReplyDeleteI saw Dave's spiel and I think that influenced some of my thinking.
The initial pizza parlor investments are generally $250K - $500K early stage. Generally the investments comes after the initial development is done and marketing/operational dollars are required to prove out the business model. If the founder is a super star, they may be able to secure funds with a concept.
Friends and family always come in early.
Great to meet you last night at the Boston BizSpark Meetup! Thanks for coming and introducing yourself.
ReplyDeleteSo McClure said he made 60 investments (American Idol) style for a total of $3 million which comes out to be about $50K a piece. And Pizza Parlor appears to be about $250K to $500K apiece.
Dave McClure also said his competitive advantage is his ability to write a quick check. In a way he's replacing the friends and family round without all the emotional baggage that comes with friends and family round and adding his sage advice on how to focus the startup's efforts on success. Additionally startup founders don't have to feel like they are handing over control of their baby to an Angel investor since Mcclure takes only 5% to 10% ownership.
Ideally startups should choose an investor that is a recognized expert in their niche and can give CEO-like advice from having walked the same road before. (Very impressed, by the way, by Aaron O'Hearn's laser-sharp questions for Josh Bob of Textaurant.com last night.)
Do you think we'll have a McClure-style startup investment model here in Boston so that local startups don't have to move to Silicon Valley to get the same treatment?
- Marsh Sutherland
SocialGrow.com
@socialgrow | @twitter